Design Observer

Archive
Books + Store
Job Board
Email Archive
Comments
About
Contact
Log In
Register



Change Observer

Resources
Submissions
About
Contact


Departments

Audio
Bibliography
Case Studies
Collections
Dialogues
Essays
Event-Aspen
Event-Bellagio
Event-Education
Gallery
Interviews
Miscellaneous
Opinions
Primary Sources
Projects
Report
Reviews
Slideshows
Video


Topics

Advertising
Aid
Architecture
Art
Books
Branding
Business
Cities / Places
Community
Craft
Culture
Design History
Design Practice
Development
Disaster Relief
Ecology
Economy
Education
Energy
Environment
Fashion
Film / Video
Food/Agriculture
Geography
Global / Local
Graphic Design
Health / Safety
History
Ideas
Illustration
India
Industry
Info Design
Infrastructure
Interaction Design
Internet / Blogs
Journalism
Landscape
Media
Motion Design
Museums
Nature
Obituary
Peace
Philanthropy
Photography
Planning
Politics / Policy
Popular Culture
Poverty
Preservation
Product Design
Public Art
Religion
Science
Shelter
Social Enterprise
Sports
Sustainability
Technology
Theory/Criticism
Transportation
TV / Radio
Typography
Urbanism
Volunteerism
Water


Comments (4) Posted 01.31.11 | PERMALINK | PRINT

Project

Give a Minute


Jonathan Schultz


Give a Minute homepage features a user interface modeled on Post-it notes. Courtesy Local Projects.

One needn’t be a Walden-clutching Luddite to be wary of social media’s creep into the political process. Even in the roiling urban soup championed by Jane Jacobs, what increasingly passes for public discourse is a hashtag-strewn Twitter thread. To remind city dwellers of their vital roles within both their neighborhoods and cities, a new initiative doesn’t propose turning back the clock so much as recalibrating its movement.     

“It doesn’t take a ton of insight to recognize that the existing public participation process does not really work well,” says Jake Barton, founder of Local Projects. His New York–based interactive design firm was recently charged by CEOs for Cities, an urban think tank, with what Barton demurely calls an “open” brief: to reimagine the public process for the 21st century.

His team responded with Give a Minute, a project that encourages urban citizens to organize and act to improve their blocks, stoops, playgrounds, even exercise routines, thereby drawing the attention — and financial support, where appropriate — of city officials. The model will be given its most thorough test to date in New York beginning this spring.

“In our current participation process, the powers that be plop down a plan in front of you,” Barton says. “That system is hardwired to invite conflict.” To resolve that tension and concentrate citizens’ efforts, Give a Minute would engage people through compelling public messages, and then set them using organizational and fundraising tools such as Kickstarter.com to set their own agendas.

In a pilot program last year, ads in Chicago’s El cars asked passengers, “What would encourage you to walk, bike, or take Chicago Transit Authority more?” A passenger’s response, sent via text message, triggered a reply inviting the passenger to visit a website where other people who texted similar keywords — and who consequently shared similar interests — gathered in so-called Action Groups. (The user interface, modeled on a series of Post-it notes, was also designed by Local Projects.) Members then connected to nonprofits or block associations that shared their goals.



New York’s Give a Minute, however, envisions a busy two-way street running between users and Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s office. Dovetailing with the mayor’s PlaNYC 2030 sustainability goals, Give a Minute’s inaugural question asks New Yorkers, “How do we make greener neighborhoods?”

“We’ll be reaching out to a range of stakeholders and saying, we have some ideas, you have some ideas, how can we come together and improve sustainability in your community?” says New York Deputy Mayor Steve Goldsmith. The mayor’s office is so bullish on the project’s approach to public engagement that it is offering “substantial grants” to groups and individuals who use the Give a Minute platform to effect positive sustainability outcomes, whether it’s more tree plantings on a block or a surface-water collection process that prevents sewer overflows.

“We’re not trying to control the conversation to fit some hierarchy,” Goldsmith says. “Collaborative exchange around important issues like sustainability is a positive outcome in and of itself.”

For his part, Barton hopes the majority of Give a Minute participants apply their own wits and resources to realize their goals. “Very cellular, local groups, and not just big not-for-profits, should be the primary movers of this platform,” he says.

If New Yorkers embrace Give a Minute as enthusiastically as their public servants have, solutions to city life’s most vexing sustainability issues could come not from an agency office, but from a classroom, a social club, or — horror of horrors — a Tweetup.
|
Share This Story

RSSSubscribe to Comment Feed

Comments (4)   |   JUMP TO MOST RECENT >>

Hasn't IOBY.org been doing this already for a few years? Designers (and not-for-profits with savior complexes) have a bad habit of having to do things all over for themselves. Sustainability is filled with too many replications of 'my guide to eco paper' for example. A key indicator of creativity is 'elaboration' - the capacity to build upon and extend other people's ideas. We need more collaboration - or else designers need to do better research into precedents.

(Sorry to be so grumpy about a nice idea - that IOBY.org already does...)
camerontw
01.31.11 at 04:54

The spirit of this is fine, but there's a lot to be said for getting people away from the screen and engaged with the actual place where they'd like to see change.

One particularly well-designed and poetic version of this is the Museum of Possibilities created by Melissa Mongiat, Mouna Andraos, and Kelsey Snook for the City of Montreal:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/kelseysnook/sets/72157624459314436/

Participants were asked (with some creative prompts) to come up with a specific suggestion for what they'd like to see or do in a particular place, and they could also vote on other people's submissions. Sounds a lot like the above, but the implementation is much more engaging. Check out the link above; you can't help but smile. That's good design in my opinion.
Jonathan Bean
01.31.11 at 05:49

I would love to be a part of something like this for my own community. Great way to see demand and be heard.
Ali
02.01.11 at 03:34

With more than 2,000 posts by now, the Dear City project is somewhat similar to Give a Minute. Without direct questions, people are able to address any issue they may have.

So far London, Berlin, Vienna and Copenhagen has a page but NYC and Zurich will soon be launched.

Dear City is currently nominated for the Index award and hopefully many more cities will join in order to make it a little more inclusive.

http://dearcity.org/
http://dearlondon.co.uk/
Chrish
02.02.11 at 10:40



LOG IN TO POST A COMMENT
Don't have an account? Create an account. Forgot your password? Click here.

Email


Password




|
Share This Story



ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Jonathan Schultz is a Brooklyn-based writer and editor who covers automotive and consumer-product design, electronics, pop culture and bicycle jousting.
More Bio >>

DESIGN OBSERVER JOBS









MORE BY Jonathan Schultz

03.14.11: Just Keep Truckin'
10.28.10: Solo Kota Kita
03.26.10: One World Futbol
12.08.09: EyeWriter
11.16.09: DESIS
11.02.09: Kick4Life
09.22.09: Better Place
More by Jonathan Schultz >>

RELATED POSTS


Demythologizing Design: Another View of "Design with the Other 90%: CITIES"
David Stairs reviews "Design with other 90%:Cities"

Cuba Libre: Contemporary Architecture in Havana
Young architects struggle to update the face of Cuba.

Don't Flush Me
Prototype for urban system to detect and prevent sewage overflows

Iceland: Eaten Alive, or Growing to Live?
Exploding the myth of Iceland's "green" energy — with alternative suggestions

Sleeping with the Fishes
Review of "Waltzing with Brando," an account of the actor's effort to inhabit and protect a Tahitian atoll.